Why not make another one? Good idea! You know how to play right?
January: You, X and Y go see a movie.
February: X performs in a show for you and Y.
March: You and Y sing a song to wake X up.
April: X turns into a batpony. You and X have to save him/her.
May: Scare X with the help of Y.
June: Go on an adventure with Y to save X.
July: X is your waifu and Y steals it :P
August: Y bakes you some cookies but X eats them before you.
September: Y banishes you to the moon. X is your companion forever.
October: Make a time sorbet with X and Y.
November: Y gets attacked by Timberwolves, while you are having ice cream with X.
December: Save the Galaxy with X and Y.
1: Cheese Sandwich 2: Braeburn 3: Mayor Mare 4: Smarty Pants 5: Rainbow Dash 6: Big Macintosh 7: Rarity 8: Princess Cadence 9: Trixie 10: Bon Bon 11: Doctor Whooves 12: Discord 13: Mane-iac 14: Joe 15: Apple Bloom 16: Derpy Hooves 17: Sweetie Belle 18:Twilight Sparkle 19: Spitfire 20: Snails 21: Granny Smith 22: Diamond Tiara 23: Applejack 24: Lyra Heartstrings 25: Wildfire 26: Amethyst Star 27: Button Mash 28: Starswirl 29: Princess Luna 30: Fluffle Puff 31: Flam
Y (day of your birthday this year):
Monday: Silver Spoon
Wednesday: Princess Celestia
Sunday: Dj Pon-3