Yesterday I watched all four Equestria Girls movies (not counting the EG episodes between movies). After a bit of reflection (also known as sleep), I've compiled the following scores for each movie:
- Equestria Girls [9/20]
- Story [2/5]
- Writing [3/5]
- Music [2/5]
- Enjoyability [2/5]
- Rainbow Rocks [15/20]
- Story [4/5]
- Writing [4/5]
- Music [3/5]
- Enjoyability [4/5]
- Friendship Games [19/20]
- Story [5/5]
- Writing [4/5]
- Music [5/5]
- Enjoyability [5/5]
- Legend of Everfree [17/20]
- Story [4/5]
- Writing [4/5]
- Music [5/5]
- Enjoyability [4/5]
For reference, that makes my rankings for the movies as such:
- Friendship Games (95%)
- Legend of Everfree (85%)
- Rainbow Rocks (75%)
- Equestria Girls (45%)
EDIT: For those who will protest because I gave Rainbow Rocks a low score in music, that's because most of the songs boil down to either "I am singing, the music is in me, we will beat you, we are awesome" or "We are casting a spell with our music, now you're under our control, we can't be stopped." There really isn't much that falls outside of those two categories, and it makes all of the music homogenous and not very memorable IMO.