Hello, everyone, and welcome to the next installment in the Pony Arena Game series: Pony Arena Tourney II, hosted by me, TheGuineaPig45!

And we're back! After a really long break, I have returned to finally complete Pony Arena Tourney II and the Losers Bracket! It's been a crazy ride so far, and it's only going to get crazier as we reach the game's finale! We've taken some huge loses (goodbye, (rd)), but we must continue on!

So, here's how PAGTII works: 64 user-selected characters from My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, its spinoff film series, as well as its official comic book series, have been selected to compete in the game. In each round, several matchups will take place, in which two of the competitors go head-to-head in a poll. Whichever one gets the most votes by the end of the round moves ahead, while the one with less votes is eliminated from the main competition! The game will continue this way for many rounds, until only one character remains, taking the top spot and earning the title of Ultimate PAGTII Champion! New rounds will happen every Wednesday, and four matchups will happen in every blog post.

Remember: only 4 of the 8 remaining competitors will make it to the next round. The other 4 will be PERMANENTLY eliminated. Also, please try not to flood the comments section. I encourage posting comments about the game and who you voted for, just as long as you don't go overboard with it.

And so... it continues! Let's play some...


Round 4

Starting us off is Twilight Sparkle vs. Derpy! One is a smart, strong leader as well as the Element of Magic, while the other is a muffin loving mare residing in Ponyville. Which one do you prefer?

Round Four: Twilight vs. Derpy

Twilight Sparkle: 22

Derpy: 5

Winner: Twilight Sparkle

Following that, it's a battle between unicorns: Starlight Glimmer vs. Rarity! One is a reformed villain who's trying to find her place, while the other is a well known fashion designer and a pony obsessed with generosity. Which one do you like more?

Round Four: Starlight vs. Rarity

Starlight Glimmer: 14

Rarity: 16

Winner: Rarity

After that, a battle between the two main ponies Andrea Libman voices: Pinkie Pie vs. Fluttershy! One is a super energetic party pony, while the other is a shy pony who adores animals. Which one do you think is better?

Round Four: Flutters vs. Pinkie

Pinkie Pie: 8

Fluttershy: 21

Winner: Fluttershy

Lastly, Princess Luna vs. Sunset Shimmer! Both two of these ponies started out as villains, but have since reformed and befriended the Mane Six. Which one do you think deserves the win?

Round Four: Luna vs. Sunset

Princess Luna: 10

Sunset Shimmer: 20

Winner: Sunset Shimmer

Here it is! The next round will next Wednesday. Also, please check out the newest rounds of the PAGTII Losers Bracket!

Thank you all very much for participating and supporting the series for such a long time. I hope you have fun with this newest installment! Enjoy!


  • Twilight Sparkle
  • Pinkie Pie
  • Fluttershy
  • Rarity
  • Sunset Shimmer
  • Starlight Glimmer
  • Princess Luna
  • Derpy
Pony Arena Tourney II, by TheGuineaPig45

Tourney: Round 1a1b1c1d1e1f1g1h2a2b2c2d3a3b4SemifinalsFinals (1)Finals (2)Finals (3)Closing Ceremony
Losers Bracket: Round 1a1b1c1d2a2b3SemifinalsFinals
Hall of Fame